FHA Making Changes to Upfront and Monthly Mortgage Insurance
Tuesday, August 24th, 2010Are you currently pre-approved wth FHA financing? For many, this is the way to go — minimum down payment (3.5%), lower acceptable credit scores (620) and higher allowable seller paid costs (6% of the sale price which will be lowered soon to 3%). One thing that always frustrates FHA borrowers is the Up-Front Mortgage Insurance Premium (UFMIP) and the monthly mortgage insurance. Why is FHA charging twice for the same thing? Let me explain.
First, it’s good to know that FHA is self-insured. So, if you default on your loan, they provide insurance for the investor. Whereas on a conventional loan, you pay Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) to insure the lender in case of default. The PMI is provided from an outside company and is required on all loans with less than 20% down. (Of course, if you qualify, you may be able to get the new MN Housing program that DOESN’T require PMI or a down payment!)
FHA requires the UFMIP on all loans and a monthly amount on all loans regardless of your down payment situation — minimum down of 3.5% or 50% down — you’ll still have it. One thing many people don’t know is what ELSE the FHA insurance covers. Let’s say you lose your job and are having a tough time making your house payment. Like most, you don’t want to lose your home. FHA’s insurance covers job-loss protection. FHA may pay up to 12 months of your house payment to save your home and keep your payments on time with your lender. Those payments will be added on to your loan on the back end.
Right now, the UFMIP is 2.25% of the loan amount. In all of the deals I do, this is rolled into the loan, not paid out of pocket. This will raise your payment because your loan amount increases. The monthly amount is .55% of the loan amount, divided by 12 to get the monthly figure.
Here is what you need to know: any new case numbers* assigned ON or AFTER 10/4/10 will have different UFMIP and monthly MIP. Good news is the UFMIP will DECREASE to 1% of the loan amount vs. the current 2.25%. This is a good change. The annual premium, or monthly amount, will be INCREASING to .90% of the loan amount — almost double what it was at before. So what, right? Well, let’s look at the numbers.
Scenario:
- Purchase price $200,000
- Rate at 4.5% over 30 years
- 3.5% down or 96.5% LTV
Old MIP Scenario
- Loan with UFMIP is $197342
- UFMIP that is included in above loan amount is $4342
- Monthly MIP is $88
- Principal and interest is $991
NEW MIP Scenario
- Loan with UFMIP is $194930
- UFMIP included above is $1930
- Monthly MIP is $145
- Principal and interest is $988

Difference? Payment is $54/month HIGHER with the new plan. That means, in real terms, you can afford about $7500 LESS in purchasing power. Sure, that’s the downside. But, if you stick with your home for 7 years, you will actually “wash” the difference. Though FHA will get more of your money upfront (vs being rolled into the loan), you will have MORE equity at that time than with the original plan). And, stay in your home 10 years, the MONTHLY amount should drop off assuming you’ve reached 22% equity in your home based off your original purchase price.
The moral of the story — buy as soon as you can if you’re using FHA. $7500 in buying power is HUGE! Most of you will just stay in your home for 5-7 years if it’s your first home so the “wash” really doesn’t matter. And who really wants a payment that is over $50/mo more? Not me.
So, when’s the time? Now! Why is it now? To save on your monthly payment and BUY more home!
*case number: the number assigned by FHA for your property purchase. It follows the address and is how an appraisal is ordered.





