Could Your Dispute Hurt You?
Posted on May 18th, 2010 by DarcyHuh? What dispute? The one I am having with my roommate or with my parents about buying a home? You may have many disputes going on in your life. The one I am referring to is a dispute you started yesterday or 10 years ago with a creditor.
If you’ve been one to check your credit or maybe have had some issues in the past, you may have seen erroneous “tradelines” on your credit report. A tradeline is an item of credit — car loan, credit card, mortgage, student loan,etc. Now, if I were you I would be all over that like a bee to honey. I’d contact the creditor and “dispute” the inaccurate information. Wouldn’t you? The whole goal is to get the right things reporting on your report, not items that don’t reflect your score and ability to pay on time. True. BUT one little catch. Though you’re trying to BETTER your credit situation, you are actually making it harder to get financing.
Seriously? Helping your credit/disputing an account = tough time getting a loan. Tough to follow that logic,huh? FHA is the most popular loan right now and the most lenient when it comes to credit scoring, as well as only requiring 3.5% down. However, they have this little guideline that has been creating BIG issues for folks getting home loans. The deal is, if you have disputed an account on your report, regardless of what the dispute consists of, your loan guidelines just got stricter. Yes, your loan qualifications got tighter because you were trying to help your score improve. Does that make sense? Nope, not to me, but lately, many of the “rules” and changes have caused me to scratch my head quite often.
So, what changes with your underwriting guidelines? For one, your loan must be manually underwritten. 90% of my loans are run through and approved through AUS (automated underwriting system). Information about you in … decision on a loan for you out. Slick and easy. Your file is still processed, verified and still gets in front of an underwriter for the final stamp of approval. In a manual underwrite, it doesn’t matter what the loan decision is through the AUS. It’s no longer eligible for this to move to the underwriter faster and with more assurances of getting your final approval. It now has to be reviewed in depth and documented in depth in order for an underwriter to make a decision.
The rules to follow:
- Your ratios cannot exceed 31/43%. This means you cannot spend over 31% of your GROSS monthly income toward your house payment, OR over 43% of your gross monthly income toward your house payment and other monthly debts. This is concrete; no wiggle room here. We will use the lesser payment for qualifying when choosing the payment you can be approved for.
- We must get traditional VOE’s and VOD’s (verification of employment and deposits) So, even though you provided me with W2′s and paystubs, as well as bank statements, we must still get this information from a 3rd party. No fun especially since some banks and some employers charge a fee to give us that information. Unbelievable.
- We must do a VOR which is a verification of rent. Important that we confirm you make rent payments on time. Don’t worry if you’re not renting and with family; this won’t hurt your chances of getting a loan.
- The biggest one — you must have 2 months of reserves. In layman’s terms, that means after closing, you need 2 months of your PITI payment leftover. This can include retirement. Here’s the thing. Most first time buyers have a hard enough time coming up with their down payment or minimum investment depending on the first time program the buyer uses. Now you’re saying we need money left over? Yup and it hurts.
So how do you combat this? Well, there may be a way to work on getting the dispute removed. For instance, you could contact the creditor and tell them you don’t want to dispute the account any longer. About 30 days after you call, we can re-pull credit to make sure the verbiage “account in dispute” has been removed. It’s not an ideal situation, BUT, it would allow for a faster decision, more leniency on what you qualify for and NO requirement to have money leftover after you close, though there is nothing wrong with that!
The moral of this story — don’t wait to find a house to make an offer to find out you might have to wait due to this rule. Make sure you’re getting pre-approved with a lender that knows these guidelines and looks for them when reviewing your report. Also, there are people I can refer you to with regard to credit restoration if you’re in that boat. Let me help you get ready for the biggest purchase of your life. Knowledge is power and the more you know and can prepare for now will save a lot of headaches and stress when you do buy. I think you’ll have enough of that just from doing something new!
Tags: credit, credit score, FHA, first time home buyer, loan process, loan qualifying, pre-approval

Darcy, navigating the waters through credit reports/credit repair can be dangerous. Knowing what is on your credit report has never been more important!I’m glad you took the time to go over these details. Getting a pre-approval BEFORE you look at homes is essential in todays real estate market.
go figure >_>
great blog post. I have been seeing more and more credit reports with disputes get approval in automated underwriting, then get disputes removed and the DU/LP kicking it out as refer. Disputing accounts can actually get the borrower denied! Then trying to get the disputed accounts as resolved can take 2- 4 weeks…..ouch!
Finance and Investing click here…
[...]Could Your Dispute Hurt You? | First Stop 4 Home Loans[...]…